NIH Defends Cancer Researchers' Sponsored Travel

on 2 December 2010, 11:29 AM |

Trips that researchers at the U.S. National Cancer Institute (NCI) accepted from nonfederal sponsors to present data at scientific meetings or institutions were a valid part of carrying out science and did not violate any federal rules. That's the gist of a letter sent last month by NCI and the National Institutes of Health (NIH) to Senator Charles Grassley (R-IA), who questioned the trips in October.

Grassley complained that 16 NCI intramural scientists took 10 or more "sponsored" trips a year in 2008 or 2009 that sometimes cost over $10,000. The 3-page letter stamped 18 November from NIH Director Francis Collins and NCI Director Harold Varmus (released by NIH this week after a request under the Freedom of Information Act) says "it is vital that NIH scientists participate in scientific meetings" and that allowing societies, universities, and others to foot the bill "maximizes the resources available for exchanges of new data." The letter describes the review (including for potential conflicts of interest) that proposed sponsored travel undergoes and emphasizes that employees don't receive any personal financial benefit. NIH also gave Grassley 29 pages of spreadsheets detailing the sponsors, locations, and cost of the 16 employees' sponsored and government-paid trips from 2008 through 2010.

The NIH leaders also say that they are "concerned that you may have received misinformation" about the NCI scientists' trips, in particular, that almost all were international. In fact, the letter says, the majority (57%) of the 457 trips taken by the 16 scientists over the 3 years were to domestic destinations. ScienceInsider recently drew the same conclusion—that many trips are to U.S. cities—after reviewing travel records that NIH submits to the Office of Government Ethics.

NIH's response doesn't address the cost of the trips, which rarely exceeded $5000. Nor does it discuss Grassley's concerns about the reassignment of NCI's chief ethics official after she questioned the trips.

One interesting detail is that the cost of the 16 NCI scientists' sponsored trips far exceeded what they spent traveling on the government's dime. For example, in 2010 sponsored travel amounted to $309,000 compared with $77,700 for government-paid trips. NIH intramural scientists told Science Insider that it's not unusual for most trips by senior scientists to be sponsored travel.

Email Print |
More
blog comments powered by Disqus
Home > News > ScienceInsider > December 2010 > NIH Defends Cancer Researchers' Sponsored Travel