Health concerns have been rising in Japan after the government found unacceptable radiation levels in milk and vegetables from several regions and in
drinking water in Tokyo. The radiation comes from the crippled Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant. But how worrisome are the radiation levels? And when
will the food and water supply be safe again?
reports today, two tap water samples tested in Tokyo contained 190 and 210 becquerels/kilogram (Bq/kg) of iodine-131. That level is roughly twice the limit of
100 Bq/kg for infants that's considered safe by Japan's health officials.
In response, Japanese authorities advised parents not to give babies tap water or use it in formula. Children are of special concern because any
ingested iodine-131 will be absorbed by their developing thyroid gland and can lead to thyroid cancer. (The safe level is three times higher for
Still, the risk to babies is low, says epidemiologist Richard Wakeford of the University of Manchester in the United Kingdom. According to his
calculations, an infant drinking tap water for a year that contained twice the safe level for iodine-131 would receive a dose of about 0.8
millisieverts. By comparison, the dose from natural background sources is 2.5 millisieverts a year, he says.
Nuclear engineer Shih-Yew Chen of the U.S. Department of Energy's Argonne National Laboratory in Illinois says he's "not at all surprised" that
iodine-131 is showing up in Tokyo's water because if the wind blows southward from the plant, it could carry radiation that far. Without knowing the
source of Tokyo's drinking water, however, he says it's hard to say exactly how the iodine entered the water supply. But most likely it came from
airborne dust or fell in rain or snow that fed lakes, streams, and reservoirs.
The good news is that iodine-131 has a half-life of only 8 days, so any radiation from the Fukushima plant will be gone from the water within a couple
of months once the leaks are stopped.
Japan has also reportedly banned sales of raw
milk and certain vegetables from Fukushima prefecture and some other prefectures after unsafe levels of iodine-131 and cesium-137 were detected in
samples. (The United States has banned imports of dairy products and produce from several regions.) Milk likely became contaminated when cows fed in
pastures dusted with fallout. Spinach, which had some of the highest detected radiation levels, has large leaves that collect more radioactive dust
than nonleafy vegetables.
As with tap water, safety levels are set based on the ingestion of large amounts of the food over a long time. "Unless you consumed it continuously at
a high level," the exposure level would be minimal, Chen says.
The threat from iodine-131 in food will also fade quickly once the releases stop. But cesium-137 is a different story. Once the cesium enters the soil,
its half-life of 30 years becomes a "long-lasting problem for sure," Chen says, and it will show up in vegetables, meat, and milk.
How much of a problem depends on the soil type, says retired Colorado State University radioecologist F. Ward Whicker. Clay binds the metal and keeps
plants from taking it up. But if the soil is sandy and low in clay, cesium "can be recycled from soil to plant to soil for a long, long time," Wicker
says. Authorities dealt with the problem after the 1986 Chernobyl nuclear disaster by turning over a deep layer of soil to bury the radioactive dust.
For our complete coverage of the crisis in Japan, see our Japan
Earthquake page. For Science's answers to
reader questions about the crisis, see our Quake